Photo by Ilo Frey on Pexels
Decolonizing Carbon
Deforestation, when forests are eliminated for non-forest purposes such as agriculture, accounts for 11% of global emissions (Forest Stewardship Council, 2024). Halting deforestation was identified as the lowest cost option to reduce climate risks (Stern, 2007). This resulted in the development of projects to reduce deforestation, such as Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD) and REDD+ (plus Conservation and forest management) (United Nations (UN), no date).
GHG emissions are an externality of colonially driven economic systems, meaning they are a byproduct of commercial activity unaccounted for in costs of doing business (Cambridge Dictionary, no date). Neoliberal ideology created carbon markets as a cost-effective way to internalize these externalities. Forestry offset projects (FOP) like REDD+ are funded by selling deforestation avoidance carbon credits on voluntary carbon markets (VCM) (Morita and Matsumoto, 2023). VCMs differ from compliance markets which operate under regulatory requirements to cap or reduce emissions (Montel, 2024).
However, these market-based solution face challenges. Imbalanced power relationships have prioritized colonial knowledge systems in institutional governance and decision making, resulting in little effectiveness in carbon reduction through reducing deforestation and reinforced inequities in benefit distribution (Romm, Lezak and Alshamsi, 2025). To address these challenges, we examine an alternative approach to preventing deforestation through conservation led by local peoples, elevating Indigenous and local knowledge (ILK) referred to from here as community-led conservation (CLC) (Charnley and Poe, 2007).
GHG emissions are an externality of colonially driven economic systems, meaning they are a byproduct of commercial activity unaccounted for in costs of doing business (Cambridge Dictionary, no date). Neoliberal ideology created carbon markets as a cost-effective way to internalize these externalities. Forestry offset projects (FOP) like REDD+ are funded by selling deforestation avoidance carbon credits on voluntary carbon markets (VCM) (Morita and Matsumoto, 2023). VCMs differ from compliance markets which operate under regulatory requirements to cap or reduce emissions (Montel, 2024).
However, these market-based solution face challenges. Imbalanced power relationships have prioritized colonial knowledge systems in institutional governance and decision making, resulting in little effectiveness in carbon reduction through reducing deforestation and reinforced inequities in benefit distribution (Romm, Lezak and Alshamsi, 2025). To address these challenges, we examine an alternative approach to preventing deforestation through conservation led by local peoples, elevating Indigenous and local knowledge (ILK) referred to from here as community-led conservation (CLC) (Charnley and Poe, 2007).